In September 2026, Minnetonka's median sale price was $487,000, which was 6.1% below September 2025. Over the same month the average sale price rose 11.2% to $685,887, and price per square foot rose from $232 to $257, according to the Minneapolis Area REALTORS local market update for Minnetonka. August looked the same. The median fell 4.0% to $480,000 and the average climbed 20.3% to $666,737.
The median and the average summarize the same closed sales. When they move in opposite directions, the typical Minnetonka sale is holding flat or slipping while a smaller number of high-priced sales pull the average up. For a buyer comparing west-metro suburbs, that difference decides which figure is the better guide to the house they want.
The gap between the two numbers doubled this fall
When a median and an average move in opposite directions, the gap between them shows the change more clearly than either number alone.
| Period | Median sale price | Average sale price | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| August 2025 | $500,000 | $554,226 | $54,226 |
| August 2026 | $480,000 | $666,737 | $186,737 |
| September 2025 | $518,850 | $616,759 | $97,909 |
| September 2026 | $487,000 | $685,887 | $198,887 |
A median moves only when the house in the middle of the sales list changes price. An average moves whenever a few sales at the top get bigger. In September 2026, a month with 72 closings, Minnetonka's average ran almost $200,000 above its median. Over the 12 months through September, the median was essentially flat at $499,700 and the average rose 4.7% to $625,089. The middle of the market held steady while the top of the market grew.
The split started in 2025
The pattern goes back further than this fall. Hennepin County's 2026 Assessment Report lists Minnetonka's mean and median sale prices for each calendar year. In 2024 the city's mean was $536,610 and the median was $485,000, a gap of about $52,000. In 2025 the mean jumped to $608,060 while the median rose only to $495,750, and the gap grew to about $112,000.
In the same report, the number of new single-family homes built in Minnetonka rose from 26 in each of 2023 and 2024 to 35 in 2025. The city reports issuing 36 building permits for new single-family homes in 2025. Minnetonka recorded 660 sales in 2025, so 35 new homes would be a small share of any year's closings. A handful of sales far above the middle can lift an average without changing the median, so a small group of new homes is the kind of product that can widen the gap.
Where Minnetonka's new homes are going
The city's 2025 Community Development Annual Report puts the average new home built in Minnetonka from 2021 through 2025 at 5,125 square feet.
The city's planning files show recent projects arriving one or two lots at a time, on sites that already held homes:
- Swanson Homes' Elevare 2nd Addition redevelops two existing properties on Plymouth Road into two homes on two parcels. The city council approved it on Feb. 2, 2026.
- Zehnder Homes filed Carlson's Linner Road Addition to redevelop two existing single-residence properties on Linner Road.
- Zehnder also proposed two-lot subdivisions of two properties on Oakland Road, as Oakland Woods Estates and its second addition. Lake West Development's Oakland Estates 2nd Addition, which redevelops two existing single-family properties, is another of these projects.
- Hidden Valley 3rd Addition, a two-lot subdivision on Hidden Valley Road, was approved in June 2025. Lecy Brothers Construction later asked the city to extend that approval.
None of these is a subdivision of dozens of homes. If the new houses follow the city's 5,125-square-foot average, they will sell in a different range from most of Minnetonka's existing homes, and sales like that lift an average and a per-foot figure more than a median. So can a lakeshore property or a large wooded lot that closes in a month with few other high-end sales. Monthly averages in a city of Minnetonka's size can swing on a handful of sales, and the market update itself warns that small samples can make a single month look extreme.
Mortgage rates are hitting the two segments differently
Interest rates are a second reason the top and the middle can move apart. The statewide figures suggest why buyers at the top kept closing this year while the middle softened.
The Star Tribune's September 17 report on the August market cited Minnesota Realtors figures: statewide pending sales of homes under $400,000 fell 2% in August, while pending sales over $1 million rose nearly 16%. The same article reported that starter homes saw double-digit increases in market time, while homes in every price range above $350,000 sold faster than a year earlier.
By September the top end had cooled too, but it held up better. Minnesota Realtors' September 2026 market report shows pending sales under $400,000 down 12.8% from a year earlier and sales over $1 million down 2.2%. The Federal Reserve raised its target range to 3.75% to 4.00% on September 16 and held it there on October 28. As of November 12, 2026, Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11%, up from 6.24% a year earlier. These rates are general market context, not financial advice. Confirm your own loan terms with your lender.
Minnetonka sits where these two trends overlap. Its median sale is close to the price range where statewide sales fell most, and its new homes sit in the range that held up better. Locally, homes sold faster this September than last, with days on market falling from 62 to 48, and sellers received 97.3% of their original list price.
Plymouth has the same median and a different market
The comparison with Plymouth shows the difference most clearly. In September 2026, Plymouth's median sale price was $481,325, within a few thousand dollars of Minnetonka's. Plymouth's price per square foot was $213, unchanged from a year earlier, and its average sale price was $551,629.
At the same median, Minnetonka's price per square foot was about a fifth higher, $257 against $213. A buyer with a Minnetonka budget near the median will usually get less finished space than the same budget buys in Plymouth. Plymouth's average also sat much closer to its median, about $70,000 apart against nearly $200,000 in Minnetonka, so its September sales were more evenly spread around the middle. Our look at custom build versus modern resale in Plymouth goes further into that side of the comparison.
Inventory pointed the same way in both cities. In September, Minnetonka had 209 homes for sale and 3.3 months of supply. Plymouth had 234 homes for sale and 2.6 months of supply. A buyer looking at Minnetonka's established homes this winter has somewhat more choice than a year ago and somewhat more than in Plymouth.
Which number to use
For an established Minnetonka home, the median is the closer benchmark. On that measure, the typical sale has been flat to slightly down in 2026, with the 12-month median at $499,700 through September. A rising average says little about what a typical house costs.
A buyer set on a new or recently rebuilt house should expect to pay above both figures. A new home near the city's 5,125-square-foot average is priced against other new construction, and its price depends on the lot, the builder and the finishes. Our earlier piece on what drives luxury home values in Minnetonka looks at those factors.
Owners of older homes on large lots have both numbers in play. Hennepin County's figures show the gap between Minnetonka's mean and median more than doubling from 2024 to 2025, and the planning files name the builders active on existing lots: Zehnder Homes, Swanson Homes, Lake West Development and Lecy Brothers Construction. For some of those properties, the buyer may be a builder. For a closer look at how long Minnetonka homes take to sell in each segment, see what days on market really means in Minnetonka, or browse our Minnetonka neighborhood page.
If you own a Minnetonka home and want to know which side of the median it falls on, and whether a builder might see it as a site, Steadman Team brings three decades of lot and new-construction work around Lake Minnetonka to that conversation. Request a private consultation & valuation.